A lot of people seem to think that they are entitled to spew their opinions on gifted kids, parents of gifted kids, and gifted education without having read *any* of the research or without even ever spending time with gifted children.
Here are some of the things you should stop saying on the internet, behind people’s backs, or to their faces:
1. Why do gifted kids need to be challenged anyway? Why can’t we let kids be kids? What’s the rush?
Gifted kids who are not challenged are at a greater risk of dropping out than normal kids. They’re also more likely to have bad behavior than gifted kids who are sufficiently challenged. And, if they’re not challenged early on, they can flame out spectacularly when challenged later as young adults. (All of the previous statements are verifiable from pretty much any research-based book on gifted children.)
On top of that, most children find learning to be fun and to be part of childhood. It is only adults who seem to feel the need to make learning not fun. Fight that.
2. It’s so important for kids to be with their same-aged peers. It may not be important in elementary school, but just wait until they’re old enough to drive/go to prom/go to college. Then you’ll see.
Gifted kids are often out-of-synch with their same-aged peers. It would be great for them to hang around other gifted kids their same age, but many populations don’t have a large enough population to support gifted classes, and tracking is not currently in vogue. A Nation Deceived makes a clear and convincing case that gifted kids actually do *better* socially on average when accelerated than when with same-aged peers in a normal classroom. As for driving and prom… those are not the end-all and be-all. Not all kids go to prom. Many freshmen go to prom with seniors. If a freshman hangs out with juniors, hir friends will be driving anyway even though ze can’t, and not all kids have cars or get licenses at 16 anyway. In terms of college, there are many possibilities not limited to going early, taking a gap year, taking courses at the local college or community college, and so on. There’s an exciting world of possibilities that may be even better than the status quo.
3. I knew a kid who skipped grades and ze was totally messed up.
Correlation is not causation. Gifted kids are often odd and out of synch compared to other kids. Chances are they’ll seem messed up in the view of some subset of the population whether or not they’re accelerated. Compared to gifted kids who are not accelerated, those who are accelerated do better academically AND socially, according to A Nation Deceived.
4. Being bored/miserable/picked on/the only person doing work on a group project is a part of adult life. Kids need to learn to get used to it in school.
When you’re gifted and do well in school, you can often sort yourself into a profession in which you’re more likely to be surrounded by other competent hard workers doing interesting things. Being picked on is not normal as an adult.
5. I’m so sick of hearing X complain about the problems she’s having with her so-called gifted kid, if the kid is actually gifted, which I have my doubts. Gifted kids don’t need special treatment, not like real special needs kids. She should just shut up.
It is not easy being the parent of a gifted child. Gifted children are often intense. They often do not sleep much, are energetic, are sensitive, act out, get depressed, can be crippled by perfectionism, and many other things, particularly if their needs are not being met. And society is not set up to help meet their needs in many places. Additionally, parents of gifted kids often do suffer from isolation. They often cannot talk about their kids to other parents. It is wonderful being a parent of gifted children, but there are also challenges.
6. Kids aren’t really gifted, they’re just hot-housed by over-achieving parents.
We don’t believe there is a such thing as over-achievement (that’s an opinion). However, gifted kids often achieve quite a bit without the least bit of hot-housing (that’s a fact). Parents do often provide more academic enrichment for gifted kids because that is what the child needs to help behavior and happiness, but there are generally no flashcards or pressure involved. Gifted kids often teach themselves to read. And reading is fun! All kids are sponges, and gifted kids seem very eager to soak things up.
Remember, opinions and facts are not the same thing, and sometimes incorrect opinions that are not based on actual facts can do real damage. Do you really want to be one of those people who hurts an entire group? Well, we know that none of *our* readers would, but occasionally people find their way to us via google. If you’re in that situation and you say stuff like this, knock it off.
What are incorrect “opinions” that you find annoying, gifted-related or other?