Ask the Grumpies: TIAA-Cref vs. Vanguard Lifecycle funds

CPP asks:

Do you guys have any opinions on TIAA-CREF Lifecycle funds versus Vanguard? I am currently in the former, but I could change if it makes sense. I have this feeling you guys addressed this on-blog, but I couldn’t find the post. Happy New Year!!!

This one is pretty easy.  Vanguard lifecycle funds (aka Target date funds) are almost at-cost.  The fees are almost the same as the fees would be if you put together the already-low-cost index funds that make their lifecycle fund.   TIAA-CREF charges extra for the convenience.  Vanguard will save you hundreds if not thousands of dollars over the course of your investing career.  (IIRC, it is a factor of 10 difference if you do this in an IRA, but within your 403(b) plan you will have to look at the fees yourself.)

That said, there are some complications.

1.  TIAA-CREF will send out a representative to talk to you, fill out forms for you, etc.   If you’re unlikely to do anything without someone holding your hand, this is a reason to stick with TIAA-CREF.   I do not know if Vanguard will do this for you, as we do not have the Vanguard option at our school, but my guess is you would do things over the phone if you want help.

2.  TIAA-CREF and Vanguard have slightly different ideas about what appropriate investment paths and allocations are.  My personal belief is that I don’t know any better than either TIAA-CREF or Vanguard (and they don’t really know either).  Still, you may have strong beliefs that may or may not be correct and one or the other program may better fit these beliefs.

Additionally, TIAA-CREF is not one of the 403(b)/401(k) companies that is actively trying to rip you off.  Even though their fees are higher than those for Vanguard, they’re still among the lowest in the industry.  With new legislation about transparency, fees for the entire industry may be dropping, so it may make less of a difference what lifecycle fund you choose in the future.

12 Responses to “Ask the Grumpies: TIAA-Cref vs. Vanguard Lifecycle funds”

  1. NoTrustFund Says:

    I adore Vanguard. This is a good reminder that I MUST do my old 401k roll over as it is from TIAA-Cref to Vanguard.

    This isn’t relevent for target date funds but one feature that TIAA offers that Vanguard does not is automatic rebalancing, on your birthday I believe. How great is that? And why does Vanguard not offer this?

    But at the end of the day it’s all about the low fees for me. Especially when a company like Vanguard offers so many great options- if only they would start a frontier market fund. Emerging markets are no longer emerging for the most part.

  2. Foscavista Says:

    My 403(b) is with TIAA-CREF, and I meet with an adviser once a year. (If you have $50K or more at Vanguard (Voyager Status), you can have access to a third party that analyzes your portfolio for retirement and makes recommendations based on your goals: . That is where I house my Roth IRA and non-retirement funds.) Both TIAA-CREF advisers were not fans of their own lifecycle funds and took the time to build me a portfolio that matched my comfort level in terms of risk.

    • nicoleandmaggie Says:

      Not TIAA-CREF specifically (they’re generally “good guys”), but more generally, it should be noted that generally advisers make more money when they “build a portfolio” rather than using an index fund or lifecycle fund made from index funds. This will vary by company and their policies for kickbacks, as well as their fees for doing the lifecycle fund. There’s a reason DH’s tiny town has TWO Edward Jones offices but isn’t big enough for a McDonald’s.

      • Foscavista Says:

        You are right; I did ask them if they got a cut, and they said no. (Sorry, didn’t think that to mention that.)

  3. Comradde PhysioProffe Says:

    You guys are very smart!

  4. Debbie M Says:

    I have no interest in advisers, but Vanguard has gone to bat for me pretty much every time I’ve tried to do a rollover. (I say “tried” because after I quit my job, I still showed up in my employer’s database as employed and thus ineligible for a rollover right until I got re-hired and was thus, as a prospective employee, ineligible for a rollover. Not Vanguard’s fault.)

  5. 2013 in review: A summary from WordPress | Grumpy rumblings of the (formerly!) untenured Says:

    […] Ask the Grumpies:  TIAA-Cref vs. Vanguard Lifecycle funds 8 comments January […]

  6. What makes a blog post popular? Drama or the hope of redneck jokes? | Grumpy rumblings of the (formerly!) untenured Says:

    […] Ask the Grumpies:  TIAA-Cref vs. Vanguard Lifecycle funds 8 comments January […]

  7. 2014 WordPress Year in Review Report | Grumpy Rumblings (of the formerly untenured) Says:

    […] Ask the Grumpies: TIAA-Cref vs. Vanguard Lifecycle funds 10 comments January […]

  8. Grumpy Rumblings 2015 Year in blogging | Grumpy Rumblings (of the formerly untenured) Says:

    […] Ask the Grumpies: TIAA-Cref vs. Vanguard Lifecycle funds  January […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: