RBOMoney (mostly staining the deck)

  • For Nibling 1’s Christmas present, DH’s brother suggested sending him money instead of directly to Nibling 1 because he’s buying a Valve Steam Deck game system for Nibling 1.  Apparently it is like a really expensive switch, or a really cheap PC in the shape of a portable gaming system.  In any case, it’s expensive.  So I guess we’ll be buying ~1/9th of one.  This seems reasonable to us!
  • We tried to hire a handyman to stain our deck for us.  Whenever we do it ourselves, we regret the time and effort spent and wish we’d paid someone.  But finding someone to do it is difficult.  We will find someone we like and they’ll do all sorts of stuff for us and then they will just disappear when we try to find them a year or two later.
  • Professional painting companies charge a lot if you just want them to come out for the deck.  I’m not sure why, because you’d think they’d be able to do it the cheapest since they own and know how to use all of the equipment and have trained people doing it.  But even the people who charge reasonable prices for indoors seem to charge crazy prices for decks.  It may be that it’s just too small a job to be worth it to them.  Apparently when we were getting our inside house painted before we went on leave one year, they did the deck for just $600, so that would track with the having it be part of a larger job.
  • Last time (two years ago) we needed a few boards replaced and we were getting our fence replaced already, so we paid the same people to fix and stain our deck.  It was not cheap, but I remember feeling like it was probably worth it.  I don’t know how much the deck part cost, but the entire bill including some crazy brickwork stuff for our fence was $5400.
  • DH has replaced boards before and done a good job with it, but even just staining the deck takes a couple of days.  New boards is a two person job over several days.  First you measure and cut.  Then you take the old ones out and put the new ones in and hammer gun them.  Then you have to wait a few days or some amount of time that may even be longer.  Then you wash the deck.  Then you wait for it to dry out and for the weather to be nice.  Then you stain a coat.  Then you wait a day or two and stain another coat.  Then you go over the new boards.  If you don’t wait long enough you end up with sap or something bubbling up through the paint, and then that part of the paint scrapes off.
  • It looks like back in 2020 we also had to replace boards.  That cost was $1126, which we thought was reasonable.
  • In 2018, DH did it himself because we gave up finding someone.
  • This time though, we just needed cleaning and two coats of stain. We tried a new handyman that one of my colleagues recommended and he said $1300.  Now, inflation has been high, but it hasn’t been that high.  Inflation, in fact, suggests the cost should be something like $750.  I was expecting something around $800, and almost certainly under $1000.
  • We have to rent all sorts of stuff from Home Depot, which some handymen have to do and some don’t.  But even so… $1300 really does seem high for just cleaning and painting.  Unless there’s been huge amounts of inflation in the cost of stain, but I somewhat doubt that.  The internet suggests that the high-end of deck staining across the country should be around $1,250, and we’re generally not in the high end for house work given the lower cost of living around here.
  • Presumably there’s someone who could stain our deck for a more reasonable amount, but finding that person will be non-trivial.  We had asked around but only gotten this one lead.
  • So, we have given up on finding someone and DH and DC1 scrubbed the deck and bought stain yesterday (~4 person-hours, or 2 hours total with both of them working) .  He opted not to powerwash or to use fancy painting equipment this time (I guess we still have the flat push paint applier from before), so the total materials cost is under $200, though of course there will be labor costs, and we’re never quite as good at not getting a little stain on the walls no matter how carefully we tape.  Maybe two years from now we’ll be more successful finding someone to do it for us, but for now I guess we’ll be saving $1,100 in exchange for our own labor.

Do you have a handyperson?  How do you get big projects around the house done? 

18 Responses to “RBOMoney (mostly staining the deck)”

  1. delagar Says:

    When I need someone to do anything, I ask Facebook. People on FB love to give recs. I don’t know if this would work for you — I have a really WIIIIDE FB following.

  2. CG Says:

    I am our handyperson, but I wish we had a real one. :)

  3. Linda Says:

    It is difficult to find a good handyman who doesn’t just disappear if you don’t have regular jobs for them. I usually look at the Nextdoor app for names and recommendations. I had several handyman-type tasks addressed early this year when the main carpenter who had helped my contractor build the addition was on break due to the contractor needing some surgery. I was familiar with this person’s work and happy with it. The only things I need addressed now are ones that I can do myself if I make the time (like fixing a leaky fixture in the bathroom) or projects that are bigger than handyman-sized ones (like replacing some windows and addressing cracks in the stucco on the outside of the house.) I’m so flat broke, though, due to the costs of the addition and that extra work I had done that a project like window replacement has to wait.

  4. Alice Says:

    My husband was raised to be handy, to a degree that I think wasn’t actually that good for his childhood, but is very good for our house.

    My problem is when there’s something that we need to get done by someone else, because I tend to not even get callbacks about things. We had a roof/skylight problem last spring. My husband did what was meant to be a temporary fix and stopped the leak. BUT I cannot for the life of me find any roofing company that will call back, let alone give a quote. I left messages on voicemails and with receptionists at a good 5-6 places. I think the job is too small for them to think it’s worth their while, and the temporary fix is still holding… but I can’t say I’m actively comfortable with the situation.

  5. First Gen American Says:

    I would love a handy person BUT we live in a small market and usually people can’t commit to when they will show. The best ones are really busy, the ones who are available are usually bad or give really highball quotes because they don’t really “need” the business. We have a project next year that needs a contractor and lead time with our regular guy is almost a year. He would normally not take small jobs like ours as we are “filler work”. If we hadn’t spend 6 figures with him early on, he wouldn’t even be an option as he mainly wants to do whole house Reno’s where his guys are at the same place for weeks or months.

    Just an idea, but can you lump a few jobs together so it’s more palatable?

    • nicoleandmaggie Says:

      We don’t have a few jobs… also we have no handyman to give them to.

      It’ll be a while before we need internal house painting again. Doesn’t seem worth it just to save some money on the deck.

  6. Socal Dendrite Says:

    This is a sad topic for us. My husband is very handy and enjoys getting things done around the house. At least, he did before his chronic fatigue showed up 7 years ago. We have all kinds of jobs piled up because he has to take each one extremely slowly, which is very frustrating for him. What should be done in a weekend takes a month or more and leaves him exhausted. [I am (a) not handy and (b) have my hands full dealing with everything else with the household/kids.] We really need to find a good handyman but they are are to come by for the sort of small jobs we need doing and, in our area, expensive.

      • Alice Says:

        Despite my utter lack of success with getting some roof people on board at my house– one thing that worked for me in my old house was reaching out to my real estate agent and getting her to recommend someone to reach out to. I had good luck with that approach for several years– she and I became friendly enough during the house search/purchase timeline that she told me that I could reach out for that sort of thing if I ever needed to.

        Around here, agents generally have an evolving list of go-to area people who they’re used to being able to tap for a bunch of pre-sale work that needs to be done on a faster timeline. The only reason that’s not an option for our current house is that the agent we used to buy this place isn’t focused on this area anymore.

      • nicoleandmaggie Says:

        We’ve done that in the past— our real estate agent is the spouse of my department head. Hasn’t worked out for the deck, though it has for other things.

  7. Lisa Says:

    I was going to suggest the same thing – we’ve had the best luck finding handypeople through real estate agents. If it’s been years since you bought your house, if there’s an agent who lives in the area or works in the area they might be able to help. Also to echo the frustration about smaller markets. We had a much easier time finding people to help us out when we lived in an area with 10 million + people than in our current (and still not so small) market of 1.5 million + people. My sister in law lives in a tiny somewhat remote area and it sounds like there’s a lot of DIY with duct tape and flex seal type work going on there.

  8. SP Says:

    My husband is really handy and does most of that stuff, including stuff we maybe would be better off hiring out.

    We have an occasional “gardener” we are friendly with who has helped with some seasonal or one-time landscaping tasks, who we found through neighbors (and also through the fact that he lives in his van that he often parks in our quiet neighborhood). For specialized tasks, we also have relied on neighbor recommendations. Once my husband got a small plumbing job because a plumber we’d used on a larger task happened to be doing work next door, and he was willing to come over and do our task on short notice. We have used realtor recommendations, but not recently.

    Handymen specifically are tough, though.


Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.