After graduate school, before tenure, a lot of academics wonder if they’ve made the right decision. Is this really what we want to be doing for the rest of our lives, and at this institution, in this geographic region? We start to notice things like there’s life outside of work and if we don’t start now our youth will have slipped away before we enjoy it. Our similarly smart friends who didn’t go into academia or graduate school often have spouses and children and money and houses and they’re living where they want to be living. Some of them are even independently wealthy and in partial retirement.
It’s hard because it’s not too late to change. It’s not too late to forget that we made these decisions and try to do something completely different. (Of course, it is never too late to change… but given that employers like best to hire folks in their 30s, it’ll take more effort on the other side of that decade.) Folks at our stage are not necessarily miserable, but they do notice that in general things are not perfect. We wonder if making a change is going to destroy everything or make things better. It’s scary.
And even when the impostor syndrome isn’t keeping us down, the current economy is making our outside options not quite so attractive and diminishes our ability to take risks. It’s not obvious that the alternatives out there if they exist are better. If we’re not truly miserable, it’s harder to make that jump. If we are truly miserable, then sometimes that jump is worth taking anyway.
Going through this pre-mature mid-career crisis and watching many many of my academic friends and colleagues do the same in the past few years I’ve come to a few conclusions:
1. Life is a journey, not a goal. Things are never all good or all bad. Even if things aren’t great today, you can make a plan to make them better in the future. When we’re smart and educated we can create an escape plan, even if it involves doing something completely unrelated to our current skills and experience. That escape plan helps us enjoy today too because we are never truly trapped.
2. You have a LOT more options when negative shocks occur and you’re a lot less trapped if you’re good at living well below your means and have a serious emergency fund saved up. If you’ve got some extra saved and it’s making its own money, that’s even better. Not buying as much house as we could afford (keeping fixed expenses down), and living like graduate students even after we’d gotten a real salary until we had a real measure of security, has allowed us amazing opportunities to explore and keeps us from ever feeling trapped or too stressed out about our specific situations. We put in our time being poor, saving too much by some measures, and it was completely and totally worth it. Thank goodness for us in time t-n. Scrimping and saving now buys freedom later. That freedom is priceless, no matter what Suze Orman says about the importance of using loans to consumption smooth when you’re young.
3. If your health is being affected, you need to take a break. Even if you don’t have the money to do it. Talk to friends and family outside your department/university and come up with an escape plan.
I didn’t come to these simple conclusions alone though, and even if I knew them rationally I didn’t really understand or internalize them, just like folks reading are probably not internalizing them from my brief paragraphs. Your Money or Your Life is really not the best written book, and the introduction of the new edition is waaay too preachy on the subject of environmentalism, BUT it is an incredibly thought provoking book and an amazing read. Before reading it, I did not realize the things that are actually possible, even on a modest income. I thought I understood money and rationally I did, but I didn’t really internalize exactly how money really is time and freedom in addition to goods and services.
I read YMOYL. It made me think. It made me dream. It gave me a path to freedom which grants its own mental freedom. Then I made DH read YMOYL. It snapped him out of a 3 year long job-related funk. It got him interested in our finances (something that had been just me before). It made him think that maybe everything is going to be ok. I bought it for the other half of this blog. She thought it was great and got many different things out of it. DH got a copy for his colleague who can’t seem to find a job he likes– it has made him calmer and more relaxed about taking chances and I suspect has had spillover effects on his academic spouse. I suggested it to a friend who is unhappy with her current position. It helped her build a multi-year escape plan which in turn is helping her enjoy life as it is.
On the other hand, I suggested it to a lawyer I know who is completely stressed out about work and family and finances despite having a family income of something like $500K/year and she pretty much bit my head off. (I had to apologize for forgetting that some people complain in order to be listened to, not in order to solve their problems. I’m such a guy linguistically.) DH also bought a copy for his cousin with the 5 kids and the money problems and he hasn’t cracked it open yet. Similarly with another friend who just left a truly awful employment situation (but I’m sure it’ll help once she gets a copy). But still, it’s super thought-provoking and can really help with that early mid-career angst.
Anyway, I totally recommend you read it, even if you’re not going through mid-career angst. It’ll make you think if nothing else, and thinking can be fun. Then tell me what you got out of it. My friends are all getting different things, and I think that’s wonderful.
If I had to be in a book club… that’s totally the book I’d pick.
July 26, 2010 at 3:07 pm
Very true–about the book and about the importance of keeping your money in order. I was so afraid of not getting a job, and then of not getting tenure, that I became a super-saver. Then I was saving in case my kids wanted to go to Prestige U. (They chose freebies courtesy of National Merit).
Meanwhile, I have the savings. There is NOT ONE THING I regret NOT BUYING. Recently, we have had a major financial crisis. A number of tenured people were let go.
If such were to happen to me and DH, we would live in Europe for a few years, rather than seek out a job that’s probably no longer there.
Savings definitely = Less Stress.
Each new crisis reminds me of that!
July 26, 2010 at 9:46 pm
Precautionary savings really are wonderful– and if you never need them then you get to enjoy them! Freedom is so precious.
July 31, 2010 at 10:59 pm
I think you’re right that that’s probably a good book for the non-PFfy inclined to get interested. PiC is relatively open but I’d really like him to have the fire I do, or at least a bigger spark of interest!
July 31, 2010 at 11:49 pm
August 3, 2010 at 7:37 am
[…] An homage to Your Money or Your Life […]
August 17, 2010 at 4:08 pm
People should remember to save. I finished a PhD at 30 with no savings, and the had moving expenses, furniture expenses, and research expenses, in addition to student loans. Everyone kept saying, take out more loans, especially to fund research expenses. They said, getting tenure is more important than saving, and eventually you will get a raise or a good job that will be a windfall greater than any fund you could start establishing now. All of these were arguments to wage slavery, of course…
August 17, 2010 at 4:38 pm
Wow, Z, that’s terrifying. Did you manage to get out of that?
November 4, 2010 at 8:45 am
Thanks for discussing YMOYL. I think I will get it because it sounds very interesting.
November 4, 2010 at 8:47 am
It’s a wonderful book and a must-read for anyone. Everybody I know gets something different out of it.
January 17, 2011 at 11:31 am
coming up for tenure, not positive and man iam scared–very scared
January 17, 2011 at 11:33 am
February 13, 2011 at 9:22 am
[…] and Maggie both read and reviewed it. They had the same experience I did. After I read the book I kept handing it out to everyone I […]
July 14, 2011 at 1:33 am
[…] Pre-tenure Angst and a life-changing book recommendation […]
August 26, 2011 at 9:56 am
Another blogger (Consciously Frugal) is always recommending this book as well and I keep thinking that I already know a lot about finances. However I may need some inspiration and this book could be it. I would also like my husband to read it but he has little interest in finance and I have the feeling that he’ll never open it. I also know 2 friends who could really really get something out of these types of books but they’re also unlikely to read it since they practice financial avoidance despite significant financial stresses.
August 26, 2011 at 10:12 am
It’s not really about finances per se. It’s about life. It doesn’t have advice like say Dave Ramsey or David Bach. It’s more of a thinky kind of book.
August 26, 2011 at 3:39 pm
it’s a great book, makes you realise you’re exchanging your life for dollars. I read it when I was young and I think it’s one of the reasons I have no problem changing jobs when I’m not longer satisfied or I just want to do something else. I’m actually considering going back to uni for a Phd as one possible future option, once I can work out the finance side of things.. we will see! :)
August 26, 2011 at 4:34 pm
I like its message about taking calculated risks, with an emphasis on the calculated part, too.
August 27, 2011 at 1:47 am
[…] Most Helpful Post: I’m going out on a limb here and suggesting the Your Money or Your Life pre-tenure angst post. I don’t know if it’s actually helped any academic readers, but I was happy to see a […]
October 20, 2011 at 1:24 am
[…] Why you should read Your Money or Your Life. […]
December 8, 2011 at 1:47 am
[…] are useful, powerful, and different enough to change EVERYTHING. Your Money or Your Life : See our post on this phenomenal book here. If you haven’t read it yet, read […]
January 28, 2013 at 1:13 am
[…] post makes more sense. :) Also, it’s an awesome idea by itself, thanks go to the book Your Money or Your Life for initially posing […]
March 18, 2013 at 7:03 am
[…] a lot about financial independence as a side-note and we’ve talked a lot about the book Your Money or Your Life (and some about Mr. Money Moustache and Early Retirement Extreme), but mainly in the context of […]
March 14, 2014 at 1:06 am
[…] you thinking you’re going to get? How much do you like your jobs? Do you want to retire earlier or later? Do you want an upper-middle-class retirement or do you want to live a simpler life? […]
August 8, 2014 at 1:33 am
[…] Pre-tenure angst *read this book*. If you feel trapped, this book will help you feel untrapped and will give you the tools you need to get to freedom, whether that includes staying where you are with an exit plan or making a big jump. It will help you turn the risk of losing/leaving your job into a calculated risk, increasing the upside and decreasing the downside. […]
December 12, 2014 at 1:43 am
[…] quitting, read this book, it provides things to think about financially in terms of your escape route. Both #1 herself and […]
August 17, 2015 at 1:29 am
[…] savings rate and is a wonderful thing to have even when you’re still working. We talk about how having partial financial independence as a goal can make your life a lot less stressful because you will not be trapped by a bad […]
March 11, 2016 at 1:15 am
[…] Start saving up now and think about how not to get into debt. Read your money or your life. […]
March 28, 2016 at 1:37 am
[…] our family units has been able to escape terrible jobs without a new job lined up. Money really can buy freedom and peace of […]
January 27, 2017 at 1:44 am
[…] you haven’t yet, read Your Money or Your Life. Here’s our post with more info on the […]
September 4, 2020 at 1:11 am
[…] Your Money or Your Life was pretty life changing. […]
May 5, 2023 at 1:07 am
[…] Your Money or Your Life is pretty good for the third on that list. If you have money saved up, it’s much easier to do 1. and 2. If you can’t, then figuring out what you need to do so you can can by itself bring hope. […]